The publisher's final edited version of this article is available at Soc Sci Res. But if people are born gay — in the same way that people have no choice as to anti same sex adoption arguments for gun in Whyalla they are black or white — discrimination against gay men and lesbians would be vastly more difficult to justify.
A strong case can be made for using families anchored by continuously married heterosexual couples as the benchmark; these families, although declining as proportion among all families except among those with at least a college degreestill represent the most common setting of childhood. The gain to society by subsidizing only fertile married couples is far outweighed by the costs that would be associated with accurately testing all engaged couples for fertility.
Advocates for Youth, an organization that works in the U. Given some of the complexity of the family lives detailed above, a sample of young adults who report a lesbian mother and 73 who report a gay father are frustratingly inadequate for doing anything but broad comparisons across family characteristics.
Reproduction is the fundamental occurrence on which the future of life depends. Read More. It is plausible to suspect that legal recognition of homosexual civil marriage would have similar consequences anti same sex adoption arguments for gun in Whyalla the institution of marriage; that is, it would further destabilize the norm that adults should sacrifice to get and stay married for the sake of their children.
Much of what gay partners should have been able to do for each other had to be shouldered by the community at large, unnecessarily draining resources. Share Flipboard Email. But the research in this area is quite preliminary; most of the studies are done by advocates and most suffer from serious methodological problems.
The Right Prescription. The issue at hand is not anything regarding the homosexual community as a whole, or anything concerning same-sex marriage, but instead is simply the idea of a gay couple adopting a child. Homosexual couples using in vitro fertilization IVF or surrogate mothers deliberately create a class of children who will live apart from their mother or father.
Even if the concern had a rational basis and polygamy rates were to spike suddenly, there's a simple solution — propose a constitutional amendment banning polygamy. Daily Folios and Consecutive Sentences.
While the cultural and legal battles over same-sex marriage certainly are behind the immediate concern, the social science interest in children raised by gay or lesbian parents is also driven by the larger revolution in family life that children are experiencing.
Copyright notice. He also concluded that lesbians are times more likely to die of murder, suicide, or accidents than straight women. These claims have been picked up by a number of anti-gay groups and individuals, including Bryan Fischer of the American Family Association , as proof that gay men and lesbians are violent and sick.
Most child molesters, therefore, are not gay people lingering outside schools waiting to snatch children from the playground, as much religious-right rhetoric suggests.